
Second, I contacted the coordinator of the Spring Into Romance contest and my entries got lost by the US Postal Service. I got no comments, no scores, nothing. That's the last contest I'm entering by mail.
Third, I just got done judging 7 entries for 2 different contests. I hope I didn't crush anybody's drive to write. I didn't sugar coat any of my comments, but I wasn't nasty either. Just blunt. One thing you get from me when I judge is a whole lotta feedback. It might not all be gushy complimentary, but it's geared toward improving the entry. And after 30 contest finals with 8 books in 3 genres, I think I can speak to what works.
I avoid saying: I don't like your hero/heroine, although that is often my first impression. Instead, I try and say things like: you have not shown your hero's motivation so he's hard to root for.
I did--heaven help me--take one entry's plot and explain how I would have done it differently given the same premise. If someone had done that to me, I probably would have screamed bloody murder. It's my story and I'll tell it however I want to, however bad that might be. But the story intrigued me enough that I thought if I could show her how the events could be rearranged to make the plot more feasible... we'll see what happens.
When I judge, I do so with an eye towards making the entry ready for an editor/agent to look at it. A manuscript can't just have great imagery and good writing, it has to have conflict, tension, interesting twists to old plots.
You would not believe how much backstory I read. ARG!!! Doesn't everyone by now know not to do info dumps? POV seems to be a good indicator of whether the author is a big time newbie or someone who has been writing for a while.
Every single entry needed major help on the internal conflict. As in, there was none.
Another problem is the synopsis. When you've got a page limit, there's a play by play up front and a quick: everything gets resolved and they live happily ever after (no, I'm not kidding or exaggerating about this).
That's all I got for today.
Today's goal: Finish judging all my entries
Yesterday's achievement: 500 words on YA
What I'm grateful for: Uplifting feedback from final judges
Quote: "It pays to be obvious, especially if you have a reputation for subtlety." -Isaac Asimov (1920 - 1992)